Page 1 of 1

Scientific illiteracy as explained by PhD Comics

PostPosted:Tue May 19, 2009 1:03 pm
by Mental
Image

I would say this is a good metaphor for the autism vaccine debate we were having earlier this month, no?

PostPosted:Tue May 19, 2009 8:52 pm
by SineSwiper
Replay wrote:I would say this is a good metaphor for the autism vaccine debate we were having earlier this month, no?
True, but at least it spawned about 100 research projects relating to mercury, autism, vaccines, et all to prove one and for all that Jenny McCarthy is not a scientist and is fucking crazy.

Although, it brings up a good point. Just how hard is it to publish a peer-reviewed study? Let's say that you're a good scientist, and you want to test a theory and make the results known as "good science". However, this theory is unpopular, not on the news, not a hot topic, etc.

Do you need grant money? Do you need hundreds of thousands of dollars and access to a huge lab to do an experiment? (Let's say it doesn't involve a super collider.)

What I'm really asking is: Is science politically driven, and is politics the only way to get anything scientifically proven? Stuff like global warming isn't what I'm talking about. Yeah, the Republicans tend not to believe it, but the science is THERE. There's hundreds of studies on it. What about the weird crap that we've never investigate because anybody with an interest in it doesn't have the money to dive into a scientific study?

PostPosted:Fri May 22, 2009 8:21 pm
by SineSwiper
Kupek?

PostPosted:Fri May 22, 2009 8:30 pm
by Kupek
Sorry, I'm just not up to writing what is essentially a short essay on research right now.

PostPosted:Sat May 23, 2009 6:58 am
by Zeus
Kupek wrote:Sorry, I'm just not up to writing what is essentially a short essay on research right now.
So the question is: if I spend a good hour plus writing up my theory on morality that we discussed earlier, would you have the time to respond in kind? It would be a long debate

PostPosted:Sat May 23, 2009 9:23 am
by Kupek
Seeing as how I'm going to Rome for a conference, then I'm going to go visit two of my best friends in Barcelona for a few days, and then once I get back move up to NY for three months for another IBM Research internship, probably not anytime soon.