Amazon.com reviews? I would wait for a reputable source before listening to amazon.
Though if this game does turn out to suck, I would be highly disappointed as I have really enjoyed the remakes of 4 and 5 so far and have been looking forward to this one. It seems to be that they are complaining mostly about differences in the game when compared to the rest of the series though; someone mentioned that these are the same people who slam anime/manga when a girl in it that they like gets a boyfriend because she is no longer "pure".