Don wrote:The original Megaman 1-3 are the highest selling Megaman games so I assume you're referring to that as to why it has to be old school.
But this is only because back when all the games look ghetto, a Megaman game looks decent enough. As competition improves, the sales decline because while having a FMV at all in the PS1 era makes you pretty stand now, now it takes more than that to impress anybody.
Super Mario 3 is one of the highest selling Mario games ever. I'm pretty sure there are a few Mario games it outsold so does that mean they need to return to NES graphics too? And yeah there's like New Super Mario Brothers but even that looks a lot better than NES. You can make stuff have a retro style without throwing away 20 years of progress in gaming.
You are missing some very key points:
* Super Mario Brothers 3 in its original form sold millions on Virtual Console. This is evidence that people still like games with NES graphics.
* The Mega Man series was off the radar, whereas Mario is the top gaming franchise on the planet.
* New Super Mario Brothers costs five times as much as Megaman 9
* There IS a market for retro style games (graphics included). Mega Man was a good franchise to resurrect for a retro style game. It was a major franchise in the NES period.
* If they released a regular Mega Man game without anything special (such as retro style), no one would care about it.
* If a Super Mario Brothers 4 came out for 10 bucks on WiiWare, and it used Super Mario Brothers 3 graphics, it would sell millions.