this week's manga
PostPosted:Wed Aug 03, 2011 2:26 pm
Hunter X Hunter finally resumes after an year+ of hiatus, but it's kind of disappointing. I guess you can't say it's bad, but people expect more than 'not bad' from Togashi especially with all these huge breaks in serialization. What exactly is the point to attach poison gas to the nukes? Just in case the nuke doesn't kill someone the poison will? Goku died from a heart attack so I don't necessarily believe superhuman beings are immune to stuff like disease, but spraying poison after a nuclear strike seems totally unbelieveable. You either believe the nuke will take them out (most logical), or if you really believe the poison will kill a guy who can take a nuke at point blank range then you should just use the poison and skip the nukes. Why doesn't Meryem launch his own nukes back? I assume he at least some nukes on hand, since the HXH world seems to be one where nuclear proliferation is widespread but checked by MAD. Otherwise why make the first nuclear strike look like a terrorist attack? Just have Netero call it multiple nuclear strikes and that'd be that.
This week's part also talks about how the Royals are split over Komugi. It's kind of late to talk about this after the Cat already died! The whole Royal split seems to be a lot like Asimov's Law of Robotics, i.e. all the Royals are always unconditionally loyal to Meryem but each of them has a different interpretation of what it means to be 'unconditionally loyal'. But having the Cat die very early sidesteps the conflict entirely.
Other manga...
One Piece: This week fails at the basic 'one guy versus a lot of weak guy' stuff. If you're having one guy fighting 10^(large) number of weak guys, you pretty much never have the one guy as your strongest guy because nobody is ever impressed with wiping out 10^(large) number of weak guys. If you want to use big numbers, at least use numbers like 99999999999999999999999999.9999999999 like they do in Hong Kong manga. I can buy it if Uesop or Chopper took out an army of 100K, but Luffy taking out such an army isn't an accomplishment. OP's concept of an 'army' is probably the weakest collection of individuals ever known to fiction. A 10 year old with a gun is almost certainly more dangerous than an army of any size. I can't think of a case where an 'army' in OP has ever done anything besides getting owned.
Bleach: The whole Excution arc makes no sense. I think next arc it will reveal the last 5 volumes were just all an illusion and they're still fighting Aizen.
Naruto: Still fighting... this week's arc reminds us that there's a guy named Sasuke who is still important to the story, in theory, even though no one is really sure why.
Ravages of Time: They should change the main character to Zhang Liao, since the alleged main characters never do anything of significance. Given that RoT pays relatively little respect to what actually happened in history, I think it's not too late to say that Zhang Liao has been infused with the spirit of Lu Bu and is going to create his new kingdom. It'd certainly be a lot more interesting than following the chronciles of how Sima Yi is dumber than a brick or Zhao Yun vowing to never lose another battle as long as he lives and then lose immediately.
New Prince of Tennis: This is the first time someone with the power of prescience saw themselves losing. It always bugged me how all these guys can see in the future but apparently they never see a future where they lost a game, even though it's established pretty clearly that prescience doesn't give you the ability to influence the future. Naruto characters can also learn from this month's NPOT where Yukimura's eye powers got countered by a mirror. If you think about it, that makes a lot of sense.
This week's part also talks about how the Royals are split over Komugi. It's kind of late to talk about this after the Cat already died! The whole Royal split seems to be a lot like Asimov's Law of Robotics, i.e. all the Royals are always unconditionally loyal to Meryem but each of them has a different interpretation of what it means to be 'unconditionally loyal'. But having the Cat die very early sidesteps the conflict entirely.
Other manga...
One Piece: This week fails at the basic 'one guy versus a lot of weak guy' stuff. If you're having one guy fighting 10^(large) number of weak guys, you pretty much never have the one guy as your strongest guy because nobody is ever impressed with wiping out 10^(large) number of weak guys. If you want to use big numbers, at least use numbers like 99999999999999999999999999.9999999999 like they do in Hong Kong manga. I can buy it if Uesop or Chopper took out an army of 100K, but Luffy taking out such an army isn't an accomplishment. OP's concept of an 'army' is probably the weakest collection of individuals ever known to fiction. A 10 year old with a gun is almost certainly more dangerous than an army of any size. I can't think of a case where an 'army' in OP has ever done anything besides getting owned.
Bleach: The whole Excution arc makes no sense. I think next arc it will reveal the last 5 volumes were just all an illusion and they're still fighting Aizen.
Naruto: Still fighting... this week's arc reminds us that there's a guy named Sasuke who is still important to the story, in theory, even though no one is really sure why.
Ravages of Time: They should change the main character to Zhang Liao, since the alleged main characters never do anything of significance. Given that RoT pays relatively little respect to what actually happened in history, I think it's not too late to say that Zhang Liao has been infused with the spirit of Lu Bu and is going to create his new kingdom. It'd certainly be a lot more interesting than following the chronciles of how Sima Yi is dumber than a brick or Zhao Yun vowing to never lose another battle as long as he lives and then lose immediately.
New Prince of Tennis: This is the first time someone with the power of prescience saw themselves losing. It always bugged me how all these guys can see in the future but apparently they never see a future where they lost a game, even though it's established pretty clearly that prescience doesn't give you the ability to influence the future. Naruto characters can also learn from this month's NPOT where Yukimura's eye powers got countered by a mirror. If you think about it, that makes a lot of sense.